jump to navigation

Volcanoes not evil! Volcanoes good! 22 July 2008

Posted by admin in volcanoes.

At Deep Sea News, Craig McLain reflects on the theory that volcanism was behind the Cretaceous anoxic marine extinction event and comes to the conclusion that ‘volcanoes are evil and an enemy of our salty friends’. This libellous claim has stirred the righteous indignation of Maria Brumm at Green Gabbro, who points out that ‘without volcanoes, there wouldn’t be any life on Earth at all’ and lays it on the line about those vital volcanic volatiles, the cleaning up of the atmosphere, the creation of islands and all those other things that lifeforms (salty or not) should be grateful to volcanoes for. ‘Volcanoes were here before we snotty, ungrateful hydrocarbons metamorphosed from the goo’, she declares superbly, ‘and volcanoes will be here after we’re gone’.

Evil indeed! Just because some of us might feel a little bit sentimental about a mass extinction or two.

UPDATE: Craig McLain has responded to Maria Brumm’s post. Includes nice ‘volcano of evil’ illustration.

FURTHER UPDATE: Three cheers for Chris Rowan at Highly Allocthonous, who intervenes on the side of the volcanoes. Quote: ‘Volcanoes may cause the odd extinction event or two, but they’re also a big part of why there are things to go extinct in the first place’.

The Volcanism Blog



1. mjkbk - 24 July 2008

Oh brother, more of this lame “If those evil evil volcanoes–and of course, evil evil humans–would just disappear off the face of the earth, it would be better for everyone” brand of environmentalism.

It would be hilarious if it weren’t so sadly widespread.

2. Fischblog - 25 July 2008

Sind Vulkane böse?…

Drüben bei den Scienceblogs (den englischen – die deutschen ergehen sich derzeit in recht unterhaltsamen, aber fruchtlosen Diskussionen mit Klima-[1] und Radhelmskeptikern) habe ich eine kleine Debatte im Zusammenhang mit meinem vorletzten Blogbeitrag…

Sorry comments are closed for this entry